| |
How
do we Decide?
What Are Some of the Important
Decisions I Will Have To Make?
Communication Options
Establishing
effective communication with your child is the most important
action you can take. There are different ways to communicate,
as well as different philosophies about communication choices
and sign language systems. It can be confusing for parents
who are trying to figure out what is best for their child
and family.
Fortunately,
the Infant/Family Specialist who will most likely be part
of the team of professionals who will work with your family
can help you understand your options, and determine which
options might be best for your child and your family. Again,
no two children or families are the same, and no two hearing
losses are the same. What works for one child may not work
for another.
Oftentimes
it takes a while to figure out what will work best for your
child, especially if your child's hearing loss is diagnosed
at a very young age. The best way to decide which communication
method will be best for your child is to be open to all
methods, ask many questions, talk to other parents, talk
to adults who are deaf or hard of hearing, and read as much
as you can about the different methods. In the end, you
need to do what you feel is best for your child and for
your family in general.
What
Parents Should Know About Communication Approaches
(Reprinted with permission from Communication
Options: What Parents Should Know About Communication Approaches,
BEGINNINGS for Parents of Children Who Are Deaf or Hard of
Hearing, Inc 2002. http://www.beginningssvcs.com
What
communications approaches are available for my child? What
features does each approach have? Will I need training to
use the approach? Are there specific family responsibilities
associated with each approach?
Questions
such as these are commonly asked when parents are first
learning about communication options for their child. It
helps to have a general understanding of all available options
before learning about a particular one in more depth.
When
parents have balanced and objective knowledge, they can
make choices that are right for their own child and family.
Communication
Decisions
Language and speech are two different things. Language is
normally learned through hearing it. When hearing is impaired,
special means must be devised for each child to learn that
language. Since every hearing loss is different and every
child learns differently, there is no single approach to communicating
the meaning of language which is best for all children. The
one need that all deaf and hard of hearing children have in
common is the need for effective communication of meaningful
information, including information that says "I love
you."
Advocates
of all communication approaches may tell you that their
method is in some way natural. All communication is natural
for some people under certain circumstances and there are
many ways to accomplish it. All the approaches work toward
developing communication, and they all stress things like
receptive language (understanding) and expressive language
development. Most work on speech development and all work
on reading skills. All have been successful with children
with varying degrees of hearing loss.
Many
families have chosen to use aspects of different programs,
combining what works for their child. The only thing that
makes one approach better than another is when that approach
happens to work better for a particular child. The teachers
are trained educators and they usually understand the necessity
of developing the total child. In any case, it is the degree
of a parent's involvement with the program that seems to
make the greatest difference.
Tips
for Decision Making
Do
you know what your options are for communication? Do you
understand these options? Have you examined them in person?
Do you understand all test results? How much time do you
have to devote to learning the methodology?
All
methods require a commitment on your part in order for you
to be able to communicate with your child. That everyday
commitment to communicating is the key to your child's language
development.
Remember
that the choice of educational approach must involve consideration
of the child's needs, the family situation, and the programs
available in the area. Once you have chosen an approach,
it is important to learn it and give it a fair chance to
succeed. However, if you find that an approach is not working
for your child, you should not feel locked-in to it. Another
approach may work better. You have the right and the responsibility
to re-evaluate your child's progress and request changes
when they are appropriate.
Communication
Approaches
There are several communication approaches:
American
Sign Language/English as a second language (ASL/ESL) (Bi-Bi)
- A manual language that is distinct from spoken English
(ASL is not based on English grammar / syntax). It is
extensively used within and among the deaf community.
English is taught as a second language, necessary to teach
reading. The primary goal of ASL is to be the deaf child's
primary language and allow him / her to communicate before
learning to speak or even if the child never learns to
speak effectively. Since ASL is commonly referred to as
the language of the deaf, it prepares the child for social
access to the deaf community.
Auditory-Verbal
- A program emphasizing auditory skills. It teaches a
child to develop listening skills through one-on-one therapy
that focuses attention on use of remaining hearing (with
the aid of amplification). Since this method strives to
make the most of a child's listening abilities, no manual
communication is used and the child is discouraged from
relying on visual cues, including speech reading. The
main goal of this unisensory approach is to develop speech,
primarily through the use of aided hearing alone, and
communication skills necessary for integration into the
hearing community.
Cued
Speech - A visual communication system of eight handshaped
(cues) that represent different sounds of speech. These
cues are used while talking to make the spoken language
clear through vision. This system allows the child to
distinguish sounds that look the same on the lips. The
primary goal of Cued Speech is to develop communication
skills necessary for integration into the hearing community.
Oral
- A program that teaches a child to make maximum use of
his/her residual hearing through amplification (hearing
aids, cochlear implant, FM system). This program also
stresses the use of speech reading to aid the child's
communication. Use of any form of manual communication
(sign language) is not encouraged although natural gestures
may be supported. The primary goal of the Oral program
is to develop speech and communication skills necessary
for integration into the hearing community.
Total
Communication - Philosophy of using every and all
means to communicate with deaf children. The child is
exposed to a formal sign-language system (based on English),
finger spelling (manual alphabet), natural gestures, speech
reading, body language, oral speech and use of amplification,
and sometimes cued speech. The idea is to communicate
and teach vocabulary and language in any manner that works.
Total Communication strives to provide an easy, least
restrictive communication method between the deaf child
and his / her family, teachers and schoolmates. The child's
simultaneous use of speech and sign language is encouraged
as is use of all other visual and contextual cues.
Communication
Options - Reference Chart | printable
version
Beginnings encourages parents to visit programs, talk with
professionals and other parents in order to determine which
methodology is compatible with the family and the child's
needs. It is the family's choice.
|
|
American
Sign Language
English as
a Second Language
(ASL/ESL) Bilingual/
Bicultural |
Auditory-
Verbal
Unisensory |
Cued
Speech |
Oral
Auditory-
Oral |
Total
Comm-
unication |
| Definition |
A
manual language that is distinct from spoken English
(ASL is not based on English grammar/syntax). Extensively
used within and among the deaf community. English is
taught as a second language. |
A
program emphasizing auditory skills. Teaches a child
to develop listening skills through one-on-one therapy
that focuses attention on use of remaining hearing (with
the aid of amplification). Since this method strives
to make the most of a childs listening abilities,
no manual communication is used and the child is discouraged
from relying on visual cues |
A
visual communication system of eight handshapes (cues)
that represent different sounds of speech. These cues
are used while talking to make the spoken language clear
through vision. This system allows the child to distinguish
sounds that look the same on the lips. |
Program
that teaches a child to make maximum use of his/her
remaining hearing through amplification (hearing aids,
cochlear implant, FM system). This program also stresses
the use of speech reading to aid the childs communication.
Use of any form of manual communication (sign language)
is not encouraged although natural gestures may be supported. |
Philosophy
of using every and all means to commun-icate with deaf
children. The child is exposed to a formal sign-language
system (based on English), finger spelling (manual alphabet),
natural gestures, speech reading, body language, oral
speech and use of ampli-fication. The idea is to communicate
and teach vocabulary and language in any manner that
works. |
Primary
Goals |
To
be the deaf childs primary language and allow
him/her to communicate before learning to speak or even
if the child never learns to speak effectively. Since
ASL is commonly referred to as "the language of
the deaf", it prepares the child for social access
to the deaf community. |
To
develop speech, primarily through the use of aided hearing
alone, and communication skills necessary for integration
into the hearing community. |
To
develop speech and communication skills necessary for
integration into the hearing community. |
To
develop speech and communication skills necessary for
integration into the hearing community. |
To
provide an easy, least restrictive communication method
between the deaf child and his/her family, teachers
and schoolmates. The childs simultaneous use of
speech and sign language is encouraged as is use of
all other visual and contextual cues |
Language
Develop-ment
(Receptive)
|
Language
is developed through the use of ASL. English is taught
as a second language after the child has mastered ASL. |
Child
learns to speak through the early, consistent and successful
use of a personal amplification system (hearing aids,
cochlear implant, FM system). |
Child
learns to speak through the use of amplification, speech
reading and use of "cues" which represent
different sounds. |
Child
learns to speak through a combination of early, consistent
and successful use of amplification and speechreading. |
Language
(be it spoken or sign or a com-bination of the two)
is dev-eloped through exposure to oral speech, a formal
sign language system, speech reading and the use of
an amplification system. |
Expressive
Language |
ASL
is childs primary expressive language in addition
to written English. |
Spoken
and written English |
Spoken
English (sometimes with the use of cues) and written
English. |
Spoken
and written English |
Spoken
English and/or sign language and finger spelling and
written English |
| Hearing |
Use
of amplification is not a requirement for success with
ASL. |
Early,
consistent and successful use of amplification (hearing
aids, cochlear implant, FM system) is critical to this
approach. |
Use
of amplification is strongly encouraged to maximize
the use of remaining hearing. |
Early
and consistent use of amplification (hearing aids, cochlear
implant, FM system) is critical to this method. |
Use
of a personal amplification system (hearing aids, cochlear
implant, FM system) is strongly encouraged to allow
child to make the most of his/her remaining hearing. |
Family
Resposibility |
Child
must have access to deaf and/or hearing adults who are
fluent in ASL in order to develop this as a primary
language. If the parents choose this method they will
need to become fluent to communicate with their child
fully. |
Since
the family is primarily responsible for the childs
language development, parents are expected to incorporate
on-going training into the childs daily routine
and play activities. They must provide a language-rich
environment, make hearing a meaningful part of all the
childs experiences and ensure full-time use of
amplification. |
Parents
are the primary teachers of cued speech to their child.
They are expected to cue at all times while they speak;
consequently, at least one parent and preferably both
must learn to cue fluently for the child to develop
age-appropriate speech & language. |
Since
the family is primarily responsible for the childs
language development, parents are expected to incorporate
training and practice sessions (learned from therapists)
into the childs daily routine and play activities.
In addition, the family is responsible for ensuring
consistent use of amplification. |
At
least one, but preferably all family members, should
learn the chosen sign language system in order for the
child to develop age-appropriate language and communicate
fully with his/her family. It should be noted that a
parents acquisition of sign vocabu-lary and lan-guage
is a long term, on-going process. As the childs
ex-pressive sign language broadens and becomes more
complex, so too should the parents in order to
provide the child with a stimulating language learning
en-vironment. The family is also responsible for encouraging
consistent use of amplification. |
| Parent
Training |
If
parents are not deaf, intensive ASL training and education
about deaf culture is desired in order for the family
to become proficient in the language. |
Parents
need to be highly involved with childs teacher
and/or therapists (speech, auditory-verbal, etc.) in
order to learn training methods and carry them over
to the home environment. |
Cued
speech can be learned through classes taught by trained
teachers or therapists. A significant amount of time
must be spent using and practicing cues to become proficient. |
Parents
need to be highly involved with childs teacher
and/or therapists (speech, aural habilitation, etc)
to carry over training activities to the home and create
an optimal "oral" learning environment. These
training activities would emphasize development of listening,
speech reading and speech skills. |
Parents
must consistently sign while they speak to their child
(simultaneous communication). Sign language courses
are routinely offered through the community, local colleges,
adult education, etc. Additionally, many books and videos
are widely available. To become fluent, signing must
be used consistently and become a routine part of your
communication |
 
|
|